21 S 11th St, Suite 09, Philadelphia, PA 19107

What Philly Hospital Safety Grades Don’t Tell Patients

A Philadelphia patient compares hospital safety grades before scheduling surgery, hoping an A-rated facility offers the safest care. Yet a letter grade cannot reveal everything about a hospital’s medical outcomes or specialty services. Philadelphia hospital safety grades measure selected preventable harms, but leave out procedure-specific death rates, readmissions, and specialty performance.

Leapfrog’s Spring 2026 grading system uses 32 measures covering infections, complications, medication safety, staffing, and patient experience. Several Penn Medicine hospitals also lack grades because of Leapfrog’s participation policy, rather than poor safety scores. Philadelphia medical malpractice attorneys can investigate suspected medical errors and assess whether the available evidence supports a negligence claim.

Table of Contents

  • What Is Really Behind a Hospital’s A-to-F Safety Grade?
  • How Much Did Philadelphia Hospital Grades Shift in Spring 2026?
  • Which Hospital Outcomes Never Reach the Letter Grade?
  • Can Two Hospitals Earn the Same Grade for Different Reasons?
  • Where Should Patients Look After Checking the Leapfrog Grade?
  • When Should You Hire a Philadelphia Medical Malpractice Attorney?
  • Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Really Behind a Hospital’s A-to-F Safety Grade?

Which Measures Feed Into Philadelphia’s Safety Grades?

The Philadelphia hospital safety grades are issued twice each year for most eligible general hospitals. Spring 2026 uses 32 evidence-based safety measures. Process and structural measures account for 50% of the score, while outcome measures account for the remaining 50%.

For Leapfrog hospital safety grades Philadelphia patients may see measures involving medication-ordering systems, barcode medication safeguards, nursing care, hand hygiene, communication, infections, falls, surgical complications, and other preventable harms. The final letter combines those separate measures into one overall safety score.

What Important Questions Does the Grade Not Answer?

For hospital safety scores explained accurately, patients need to know what the letter leaves out. Leapfrog focuses on preventing errors, accidents, injuries, and infections rather than measuring every part of medical quality.

It does not tell a patient which hospital performs best for a specific disease, specialty, surgery, or physician group. A hospital may therefore earn a strong safety grade without being the best choice for every medical condition.

How Much Did Philadelphia Hospital Grades Shift in Spring 2026?

Which Philadelphia Hospitals Changed Grades Recently?

Several Philadelphia hospital patient safety ratings changed between recent grading periods. Temple University Hospital–Main Campus received a B in Spring 2026 after receiving an A in Spring 2025, while Thomas Jefferson University Hospital–Methodist received a C after holding an A in both Spring and Fall 2025.

Nazareth Hospital remained at C in Spring 2026. These changes show why one letter should not be treated as a permanent description of a hospital. The underlying component measures matter when trying to understand why a grade changed.

Why Do Some Major Penn Hospitals Have No Grade?

The Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania and Pennsylvania Hospital both show Grade Not Assigned for Spring 2026. Leapfrog explains that hospitals that did not participate in either its 2024 or 2025 Hospital Survey were not assigned Spring 2026 grades.

Leapfrog applied that policy nationally after a federal-court ruling and reported 450 hospitals as Grade Not Assigned. That label is different from receiving an F and does not mean Leapfrog evaluated the hospital and found it unsafe.

Which Hospital Outcomes Never Reach the Letter Grade?

What Can PHC4 Reveal That Leapfrog Leaves Out?

Some important hospital quality measures Pennsylvania patients may want come from PHC4 instead. Its 2024 Hospital Performance Report covers 17 medical conditions and provides hospital-specific information on mortality, 30-day readmissions, case volume, and hospital charges.

Those measures answer different questions from Leapfrog’s Safety Grade. A patient comparing hospitals for heart failure, pneumonia, sepsis, or another condition may find useful outcome information that does not appear directly in the A-to-F letter.

What Can CMS Care Compare Add to the Picture?

CMS Care Compare provides broader hospital-quality information involving mortality, safety of care, readmissions, patient experience, and timely and effective treatment. These measures can help patients examine outcomes that sit outside Leapfrog’s narrower safety focus.

For example, CMS reports 30-day mortality measures for several conditions and procedures and separate readmission measures after hospitalization. Using these sources together gives patients more context than relying on one letter grade.

Can Two Hospitals Earn the Same Grade for Different Reasons?

What Might the Letter Grade Conceal About Individual Measures?

The limitations of hospital safety ratings become clearer when two hospitals receive the same grade. One B-rated hospital may perform strongly on medication safeguards and staffing but less well on an infection measure. Another B-rated hospital may reach the same final grade through a different mix of strengths and weaknesses.

That is why Philadelphia hospital medical errors should not be discussed from the letter grade alone. Patients can learn more by opening the hospital’s detailed Leapfrog profile and reviewing the individual measures behind the final score.

Can Shared or Missing Data Change What Patients See?

Yes. Leapfrog explains that some hospitals within the same health system report CMS information under a shared CMS Certification Number. In those cases, some underlying measures can reflect combined or shared data rather than only one physical campus.

Missing data also have several meanings. Some hospitals lack enough information for a particular measure, while others may not perform the relevant procedure. “Not Available,” “Not Graded,” and “Grade Not Assigned” should therefore not be treated as the same thing.

Where Should Patients Look After Checking the Leapfrog Grade?

How Can Patients Build a More Complete Hospital Comparison?

A stronger comparison uses several sources. Leapfrog can help patients review preventable safety harms and hospital safety systems. PHC4 adds Pennsylvania-specific mortality, readmission, case-volume, and charge data for 17 common medical conditions.

CMS Care Compare adds broader measures involving mortality, readmissions, safety, patient experience, and timely care. Patients can then focus on the procedure or condition they actually need treated rather than assuming one overall grade answers every question.

Why Should Patients Look at the Reporting Period Too?

A Spring 2026 grade is not a record of events that happened only during Spring 2026. Leapfrog combines measures from several data sources and reporting periods, including CMS information and Leapfrog Hospital Survey results.

That matters when a hospital has recently changed practices, staffing, or safety systems. Patients should check both the current grade and the dates behind the individual measures before treating the score as a real-time picture of hospital performance.

When Should You Hire a Philadelphia Medical Malpractice Attorney?

Which Hospital Outcomes May Deserve Closer Investigation?

Closer review may be appropriate after a major diagnostic delay, serious medication mistake, preventable infection, surgical error, dangerous fall, or failure to respond when a patient’s condition worsens. Conflicting explanations from hospital staff may also raise questions about what occurred.

A low hospital grade does not prove malpractice, and an A-rated hospital can still have an individual case involving negligent care. The medical records and the treatment provided to the specific patient matter far more than the hospital’s overall letter.

How Can a Philadelphia Medical Malpractice Lawyer Help?

Philadelphia medical malpractice attorneys may review medical records, medication logs, test results, nursing notes, operative reports, treatment timing, and other evidence. Qualified experts can then assess whether the care met the applicable professional standard.

Public safety grades can provide background, but they do not decide an individual malpractice case. The central questions remain whether the care fell below the required standard and whether that failure caused additional harm.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Goes Into a Leapfrog Safety Grade?

Spring 2026 uses 32 patient-safety measures divided between outcome measures and process or structural measures.

Can an A-Rated Hospital Be Weaker for One Procedure?

Yes. The Safety Grade does not rank every specialty, procedure, condition, or physician.

Why Do Some Penn Hospitals Have No Spring 2026 Grade?

Several Penn Medicine hospitals fall under Leapfrog’s Spring 2026 survey-participation policy and are listed Grade Not Assigned.

Can Hospital Grades Change Between Rating Cycles?

Yes. Temple and Methodist are examples of Philadelphia hospitals whose recent grades changed between Leapfrog grading periods.

Which Sources Fill the Gaps Left by Leapfrog?

PHC4 and CMS Care Compare provide broader information on mortality, readmissions, condition-specific outcomes, patient experience, and other hospital-quality measures.